2004 Tony Awards [Theatre]
    Best Actress in a Musical, Wicked
| download acceptance speech here |

2004 Broadway.com Audience Awards [Theatre]
    Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical, Wicked

2004 Broadway.com Audience Awards [Theatre]
    Favorite Diva Performance, Wicked

2004 Broadway.com Audience Award [Theatre]
    Favorite Onstage Pair (with Kristin Chenoweth), Wicked

2004 BroadwayWorld.com Theater Fan's Choice Awards [Theatre]
    Best Leading Actress in a Musical, Wicked

2006 WhatsOnStage.com Theatregoer's Choice Awards [Theatre]
    Best Actress in a Musical, Wicked (West End)

1996 Tony Awards [Theatre]
    Best Featured Actress in a Musical, Rent

2000 Drama Desk Awards [Theatre]
    Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical, The Wild Party [MTC]

2004 Drama Desk Awards [Theatre]
    Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Wicked

2004 Outer Critics Circle Awards [Theatre]
    Outstanding Actress in a Musical, Wicked

2004 Drama League Awards [Theatre]
    Distinguished Performance, Wicked

2005 Critics' Choice Awards [Film]
    Best Acting Ensemble, Rent

2006 Drama League Awards [Theatre]
    Distinguished Performance, See What I Wanna See

2006 Drama Desk Awards [Theatre]
    Outstanding Actress in a Musical, See What I Wanna See